First vertebrate with annual allochrony: Chamaeleo chamaeleon musae
Allochrony describes the phenomenon that two or more populations of a species have different reproductive cycles over time, even though they occur in the same habitat. In so-called annual allochrony, the populations reproduce at different times of the year. Allochrony is known from many different species, such as insects and corals, which reproduce at different times of the day. Annual allochrony, on the other hand, is extremely rare and has never been demonstrated in vertebrates. Two scientists from Israel have now discovered this phenomenon in chameleons for the first time.
Between 2009 and 2021, they studied the Chamaeleo chamaeleon musae populations in the Holot Mash’abim Nature Reserve in Israel on two nights per month. The reserve is located in the northwestern part of the Negev desert. During the study, the chameleons were searched for from a slow-moving car with flashlights along a 4 km long path. Animals found were measured, sexed, location recorded and claws clipped in a specific sequence for identification. All animals were released at their location within less than 20 minutes. In order to estimate the age of the animals, the time periods between the recovery of previously marked animals were used, as well as an algorithm developed using XGBoost. The chameleons could thus be assigned to the age classes < 1 year, 1-2 years and > 2 years. All data was statistically analyzed.
The astonishing results show that Chamaeleo chamaeleon musae probably occurs in two populations in the Negev desert, separated by annual allochrony. In odd-numbered years, one population of chameleons hatches in September. These animals survive until about November of the following year. In even-numbered years, the second population of chameleons hatches, whose animals also live until November of the following year. The lifespans of the two populations only overlap for a short period of time, when one population is hatching and the already adult animals of the other population are laying eggs. The reproductive Chamaeleo chamaeleon musae of both populations therefore do not overlap or only very rarely due to very few, longer-lived individuals.
The scientists were able to find a total of 1289 chameleons < 1 year old, 231 aged 1 to 2 years and 27 chameleons > 2 years old. Of these, 713 Chamaeleo chamaeleon musae had already been caught for the first time as juveniles, so that their age could be estimated very well. Only 9 of these were rediscovered between 1 and 2 years of age. The survival rate of the hatchlings until their first breeding season was extremely low. In odd-numbered years it was 1%, in even-numbered years 2.5%. Even fewer chameleons survived the first year, at 0.46% and 1.3%. Both populations of Chamaeleo chamaeleon musae were highest in the first and second month of hatching and then declined rapidly. Male chameleons were slightly less likely to survive the first breeding season than females, but overall survival rates were similar for both sexes. In each year of observation, the first hatchlings emerged between mid-September and mid-October, at the end of the hot season. During the cooler and wetter season from December to March, significantly fewer chameleons, most of them juveniles, were found.
This very exciting study naturally raises many more questions. There are several short-lived chameleons, but the entire life cycle of only a few, such as Furcifer labordi, is even known or has been studied. It is possible that there are even more vertebrates with annual allochrony among the chameleons – this still needs to be researched!
First evidence of yearly allochrony in a terrestrial vertebrate: A case study of an annual chameleon
Liran Sagi, Amos Bouskila
Ecology 106(6), 2025: e70144
DOI: 10.1002/ecy.70144
Picture: Chamaeleo chamaeleon, photographed by Markus Grimm
Science